The 6 Best Overall Student Apartments Near Amherst College (October 2026)

1. 1.

   

   North Square Apartments at The Mill District

   view → North Square Apartments at The Mill District

   5.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: North Square Apartments at The Mill District stands out as the top overall choice near Amherst College because of its genuinely responsive and professional management team. Students consistently praise Anthony, the maintenance staff member, for his hard work, respect, and speed he tackles problems quickly and does excellent work, while property manager Samantha is known for being helpful, kind, and always ready to answer questions. As one resident put it, "Anthony is respectful, polite, and takes the time to ensure everything is done neatly and efficiently." When you need something fixed or have a question, you know you'll actually get a real person who cares.

   $2195/person/mo
2. 2.

   

   Clark House

   view → Clark House

   4.8(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Clark House earns its ranking as a centrally located option in downtown Amherst that resonates with those seeking a peaceful, well-positioned living experience. The property draws residents who value its convenient downtown location and the sense of community it fosters. As one resident reflected, "It's the place I ever wanted to reach and it was one of my dreams in my lifetime," capturing the genuine satisfaction people find in calling this home.

   $345/person/mo
3. 3.

   

   Puffton Village Apartments

   view → Puffton Village Apartments

   3.6(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Puffton Village Apartments ranks high for its genuinely outstanding maintenance team and recreational amenities, including basketball and tennis courts set amid ample greenery. Residents consistently highlight the maintenance crew's exceptional responsiveness they show up promptly, even during nights and weekends, to tackle problems head-on. As one long-term resident shared, "They are incredibly responsive, always fixing issues promptly even in the middle of the night or on weekends." If you value having someone who actually shows up when you call, Puffton delivers.

   $1450/person/mo
4. 4.

   

   Aspen Heights Amherst

   view → Aspen Heights Amherst

   3.4(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Aspen Heights Amherst stands out for its beautiful grounds and leasing staff who genuinely go the extra mile to help residents navigate the rental process. International students and first-time renters especially praise the leasing office for patient, detailed support staff like Gloria have earned real gratitude for walking people through every step of signing a lease. As one international student put it, "Gloria, who always answered my questions so promptly, patiently, and in detail, and facilitated the whole process from 0 to finish." When you're new to renting in the US, having a team that actually cares makes all the difference.

   $2800/person/mo
5. 5.

   

   Kendrick Place

   view → Kendrick Place

   2.8(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Kendrick Place earns its spot as a solid overall choice near Amherst, offering in-unit amenities and responsive management when things go right. Residents praise the reliable elevator service, secure package handling, and quick maintenance responses essentials that actually matter when you're living off-campus. The in-unit washer-dryer combo is a major draw, though one resident noted it "takes forever to dry." If you're willing to overlook some noise from hallway foot traffic and the occasional party vibe, you'll find a place that keeps its promises on the operational side.

   $1390/person/mo
6. 6.

   

   One University Drive South

   view → One University Drive South

   2.5(2 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: One University Drive South stands out for its unbeatable location and practical perks that actually make student life easier. Free parking is rare in Amherst, and the proximity to two supermarkets, shops, and the rail trail means you're not car-dependent plus frequent PVTA service gets you to campus in minutes. The building itself is newer and well-positioned, though soundproofing between units is thin and move-in conditions can be spotty. As one resident put it, this is genuinely "one of the better places to live in Amherst," especially if you value walkability and transit access over isolation.

   $1750/person/mo

Walk times are door-to-door to Amherst College campus. Rent is per person, per month.