The 12 Best Overall Student Apartments Near Medical College of Wisconsin (October 2026)

1. 1.

   

   MODERN LIVING

   view → MODERN LIVING

   4.4(6 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: MODERN LIVING stands out for its unbeatable proximity to campus combined with genuinely spacious, well-designed units that students actually love living in. The standout amenities a sleek gym, huge glass windows, and generous common areas pair perfectly with responsive staff like Mary from maintenance, who residents praise for going above and beyond. As one resident put it, "The best building near campus! Glass windows are huge, gym is aesthetic & bedrooms are big." It's the rare spot where location, design, and people all align.

   $1000/person/mo
2. 2.

   

   Ascent MKE

   view → Ascent MKE

   5.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Ascent MKE stands out as the top overall choice near Medical College of Wisconsin because of its genuinely exceptional staff who make residents feel genuinely welcomed from day one. Students consistently praise the concierge team Jen and Scott especially for going above and beyond with warmth and professionalism, while the building itself earns love for its cleanliness, great amenities, and dog-friendly policies. As one resident put it, "The staff here is absolutely amazing. They will make every effort to help with anything you ask." It's the kind of place where you feel taken care of.

   $2217/person/mo
3. 3.

   

   Park at 1824 Student Apartments

   view → Park at 1824 Student Apartments

   5.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Park at 1824 has earned its rank through a genuine management turnaround that residents notice and appreciate. The new team, especially Lane and Eric, have rebuilt trust through clear communication and efficient maintenance responses that actually happen when promised. As one resident noted, "New management definitely did a good job turning things around here!" Students feel heard and supported, which makes all the difference in a student housing community.

   $599/person/mo
4. 4.

   

   Colonial Court Apartments

   view → Colonial Court Apartments

   5.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Colonial Court Apartments earns its ranking by delivering on the fundamentals that matter most: responsive management, lightning-fast maintenance, and a genuinely welcoming neighborhood. Residents consistently highlight the friendly office team, the quick application process, and the visible care the building puts into updates and landscaping. As one long-term resident shared, "The maintenance team is CRAZY fast when it comes to responding to work orders, and our apartment is beautifully updated." It's a place where you can actually relax and call home.

   $950/person/mo
5. 5.

   

   The Ritz on Kilbourn

   view → The Ritz on Kilbourn

   5.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: The Ritz on Kilbourn stands out for delivering the kind of consistent, all-around student living experience that keeps residents coming back. Management, maintenance, and cleaning staff here actually respond quickly and treat you like a person, not a ticket number. Students praise the building's quality and its unbeatable location near campus, plus the genuine sense of safety that comes from attentive staff. As one two-year resident put it, "Everyone who I was in contact with was very pleasant to deal with and answered any requests or questions in a very quick manner." This is the place where good management isn't an afterthought.

   $595/person/mo
6. 6.

   

   Alverno Pool Apartments

   view → Alverno Pool Apartments

   4.6(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Alverno Pool Apartments earns its spot by pairing solid living space with genuinely engaged management that goes the extra mile. Students consistently highlight the apartment manager's helpfulness and the standout communication from the maintenance team, who tackle work orders with real urgency. The property manager Sylvia has built a reputation for staying in touch with residents and making sure problems actually get fixed. As one resident noted, "She is always great with communication and gets the job done," and that kind of follow-through makes all the difference in day-to-day living.

   $1110/person/mo
7. 7.

   

   St. James Court Historic Apartments

   view → St. James Court Historic Apartments

   4.4(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: St. James Court Historic Apartments offers something rare: genuine character and history wrapped into your student housing. Built in 1903 and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the building delivers vintage charm with practical perks like in-unit washer/dryer access, free radiator heat, and weekly hallway cleaning. Students who land on quieter floors enjoy peaceful living with respectful neighbors and those signature tall ceilings that make old buildings feel special. As one satisfied resident shared, "11 peaceful months so far on 5th floor with no maintenance issues" and "Love the vintage tall ceilings." Just check your floor placement carefully during tour season.

   $1750/person/mo
8. 8.

   

   The Buckler by 3L Living

   view → The Buckler by 3L Living

   4.2(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: The Buckler by 3L Living has undergone a genuine transformation that's worth paying attention to. After a rough stretch marked by unresponsive management and maintenance failures, new leadership particularly property manager Misty has completely shifted the resident experience. Students now praise the clean building, helpful management, and swift problem-solving that was missing before. As one recent resident put it, "Recently, we have been fortunate to get a new property manager, Misty, who has completely changed my experience living here in a very positive way." If you're considering this property, the new era is the one that matters.

   $1295/person/mo
9. 9.

   

   Marquette 2

   view → Marquette 2

   4.2(5 reviews)FMP Score

   why it ranked: Marquette 2 stands out for delivering the kind of reliable, no-nonsense student housing that actually works. Residents consistently praise Grant's responsive management style, the included utilities (A/C and heating), spacious units, and on-site parking the practical backbone of good off-campus living. One long-term tenant summed it up perfectly: "Lived here for two years during my time at Marquette, and left feeling extremely satisfied. Affordable rent, good square footage, and amazing management that worked with us every step of the way." While one review flagged maintenance issues, the overwhelming consensus points to a landlord who genuinely listens and communicates clearly.

   $995/person/mo
10. 10.

    

    Johnson Legacy Apartments

    view → Johnson Legacy Apartments

    4.0(5 reviews)FMP Score

    why it ranked: Johnson Legacy Apartments earns its ranking by offering secure, spacious units in a quiet neighborhood with thoughtful amenities like an elevator and secured entrance. Students appreciate the office staff's friendliness and the overall cleanliness and comfort of the space. As one satisfied resident noted, "It's a very nice place very spacious and secure." The building delivers on the fundamentals safety, size, and a welcoming team that make student life less stressful. One review raised concerns about building conditions and neighborhood safety, but the majority of residents highlight the peace of mind that comes with this property's setup.

    $775/person/mo
11. 11.

    

    Playbill Flats

    view → Playbill Flats

    2.6(5 reviews)FMP Score

    why it ranked: Playbill Flats wins points for its unbeatable location just a 20-minute walk to the lake and surrounded by restaurants plus solid value for the price. The maintenance team, particularly Rick, earns genuine affection from residents for their speed and care. One resident captured the split experience well: "I lived at playbill for almost 2 years and I enjoyed my time there a lot. The management is amazing, so nice, accommodating and very responsive. Rick who is the maintenance guy, is the best!" However, the building's age means A/C and heating systems are temperamental, which has frustrated several tenants during peak seasons. If you can live with an older building's quirks, the location and staff make it worthwhile.

    $1135/person/mo
12. 12.

    

    Edge on North

    view → Edge on North

    2.6(5 reviews)FMP Score

    why it ranked: Edge on North has a genuinely friendly staff and welcomes pets with open arms a real draw for students with dogs. The leasing and maintenance teams can be warm and accommodating when things go right. One happy resident reflected, "I lived here during my last year of undergrad and it was great. The staff is amazing, so incredibly friendly and accommodating. My dogs loved it too, they're sad to have left." Unfortunately, multiple reviews raise serious red flags about management's responsiveness to safety concerns, questionable move-out charges, and overall property maintenance. The inconsistency between the friendly front-desk experience and the actual management follow-through is a significant concern that overshadows the pet-friendly appeal.

    $1575/person/mo

Walk times are door-to-door to Medical College of Wisconsin campus. Rent is per person, per month.